Research Tree Research Tree Logo

  • Try our Investor Tool
  • Login
  • Sign Up

Research Tree Logo

  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Features
  • Pricing
  • Reg.News
  • Contact
  • Try our Investor Tool
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Providers
  • Companies
⨯
LIVE

Event in Progress:

Join Here ×
  • Providers
  • Companies
⨯
  • Features
  • Pricing
  • Event Hub
  • Reg.News
  • Short Interest
  • Contact
Research >
Keep calm and carry on...

working
  • 09 Mar 2018

Keep calm and carry on...


Scottish Mortgage Investment Trust Plc (SMT:LON), 766 | Edinburgh Investment Trust PLC (EDIN:LON), 672 | Perpetual Income & Growth Invest. Trust (PLI:LON), 0 | Schroder UK Public Private Trust PLC Shs GBP (SUPP:LON), 14.6 | Polar Capital Technology Trust PLC (PCT:LON), 1,909 | Attendo AB (0RCY:LON), 0 | River and Mercantile UK Micro Cap Investment Company Ltd GBP Accum.Red.Shs (RMMC:LON), 163

  • Kepler | Trust Intelligence
    • Kepler Partners Research Team

    • 5 pages


 

Investment trusts are often the structure of choice during booming markets. The ability to gear, plus the investment freedom of a closed-ended structure allow skilled managers to capitalise on rising share prices. However, the same has not necessarily been true on the way down, as leverage exaggerates losses and discounts widen. This has often been a time to buy, with market volatility providing a chance to buy into good trusts at knockdown rates. Cherry Reynard asks, has the market rout since the start of the year produced any opportunities for value-hunters? There are 28 trusts that have seen their discounts widen by more than 5%* since the start of the year. This appears a mild reaction to the market sell-off. The FTSE 100 was down 7.5% over the same period. Peter Walls, manager of the Unicorn Mastertrust (a fund of investment trusts), said this first bout of volatility, triggered by expectations of higher interest rates in the US, passed much of the sector by unnoticed: “There was some intra-day volatility in some of the more highly geared, specialist funds. Some of the trusts that had enjoyed strong demand from self-directed investors also proved volatile – Fidelity China, Scottish Mortgage and F&C Global Smaller Companies. However, those hoping to pick up cheap opportunities were disappointed.” There were a number of reasons why investment trusts didn’t exhibit panic selling. Notably, companies proved active in buying back shares. Scottish Mortgage, for example, bought back 3,000,000 ordinary shares at a price of 449.34p at the start of March. Walls added: “The boards are aware that discount volatility is not great for shareholders and did their best to manage discounts through this time.” However, while the rout itself did not throw up any conspicuous bargains, it did exaggerate some existing trends among some familiar investment trusts. The first is the weakness of the infrastructure trusts. There were seven infrastructure trusts among those trusts that saw the greatest discount widening over the period. In some cases, the moves were extreme - GCP Infrastructure saw a 9.4% move, while HICL saw an 8.0% move. 3i Infrastructure and John Laing Infrastructure moved from a long-standing premium to a small discount. Infrastructure trusts have long been seen as a ‘bond proxy’ investment and as such, might be expected to suffer on the prospect of rising rates. However, as Walls points out, there were also other factors at work. Concerns over the collapse of Carillion and an increasingly aggressive stance from the Labour Party on PFI have weighed heavily on investors. This has unquestionably led to better value, with discounts at multi-year highs. The question for investors is whether the rising interest rate environment is reflected in current prices, or whether any further inflation shocks could send prices lower still. Simon Moore, senior investment manager at Seven Investment Management (7IM) believes a more fertile ground may be the UK Equity income sector, where sentiment has been dented by Brexit concerns. He says: “There are three investment trusts which stick out where their price has fallen significantly over the last three months. All of these have Neil Woodford/ Mark Barnett connections (make of that what you will): Edinburgh Investment Trust, Perpetual Income & Growth and Woodford Patient Capital. “These have a few UK small caps that have been in trouble, arguably nothing to do with the market sell-off, but each manager have been vocal supporters of UK listed companies despite obvious global pessimism on UK equities post-Brexit referendum. If they are right - and their judgement calls have often been right in the past - then these funds could be rerated.” Moore points out that both managers have styles that will go in and out of favour. Certainly, all three trusts have moved down a long way. Patient Capital has seen its share price total return dip 10.7% and its discount widen 5.4%. Edinburgh Investment Trust hasn’t seen a significant change in its discount, which is hovering around 9%, but its shares are down 8.6%. It is a similar situation with Perpetual Income & Growth, where the shares are down 7.7%, but the discount remains at around 9.5%. Moore says: “It is worth remembering that Patient Capital is a very different fund to either Edinburgh Investment Trust or Perpetual Income and Growth and is not for the faint hearted. Given the nature of some of the companies it invests in, there may well be more ups and downs to come. But the clue is in the name - investors who can afford to be patient may well be rewarded over the long-term." Walls sounds a note of caution, saying that some of the classic equity income type stocks favoured by these two managers are still seeing a difficult time. Some of the outsourcing groups, for example, remain out of favour with investors. Much will depend on whether investors come to believe in the ‘value’ trade, where this type of stock will revert to more normal valuations. The other sector to see some change in ratings among the recent volatility has been the technology and media sector. Of course, this comes after a lengthy expansion in the technology sector, with companies such as Facebook, Amazon and Netflix leading markets higher for much of 2017. Walls says: “A couple of the technology trusts, such as Polar Technology Trust and the Allianz Technology Trust have moved to a small discount. I wouldn’t say they look like bargains.” Walls suggests that some sectors where there should have been bargains – such as UK smaller companies – have not seen any real movement in aggregate and are certainly ‘not exciting for value-minded investors’. That said, some are certainly cheaper than they were: Chelverton Growth trust has taken a hit, for example. The other weak trust has been the River & Mercantile UK Micro Cap, though this dropped following the departure of manager Philip Rodrigs over a ‘conduct issue’. Overall, most trusts have held up well since the start of the year. This reflects well on the sector, which appears to have grown better at managing market downturns. There are opportunities, but these have arisen from issues idiosyncratic to each sector rather than market volatility as a whole

Sign up for free to access

Get access to the latest equity research in real-time from 12 commissioned providers.

Get access to the latest equity research in real-time from 12 commissioned providers.


Get Started
Already a member? Log in here

Keep calm and carry on...


Scottish Mortgage Investment Trust Plc (SMT:LON), 766 | Edinburgh Investment Trust PLC (EDIN:LON), 672 | Perpetual Income & Growth Invest. Trust (PLI:LON), 0 | Schroder UK Public Private Trust PLC Shs GBP (SUPP:LON), 14.6 | Polar Capital Technology Trust PLC (PCT:LON), 1,909 | Attendo AB (0RCY:LON), 0 | River and Mercantile UK Micro Cap Investment Company Ltd GBP Accum.Red.Shs (RMMC:LON), 163

  • Published: 09 Mar 2018
  • Author: Kepler Partners Research Team
  • Pages: 5
  • Kepler | Trust Intelligence


Investment trusts are often the structure of choice during booming markets. The ability to gear, plus the investment freedom of a closed-ended structure allow skilled managers to capitalise on rising share prices. However, the same has not necessarily been true on the way down, as leverage exaggerates losses and discounts widen. This has often been a time to buy, with market volatility providing a chance to buy into good trusts at knockdown rates. Cherry Reynard asks, has the market rout since the start of the year produced any opportunities for value-hunters? There are 28 trusts that have seen their discounts widen by more than 5%* since the start of the year. This appears a mild reaction to the market sell-off. The FTSE 100 was down 7.5% over the same period. Peter Walls, manager of the Unicorn Mastertrust (a fund of investment trusts), said this first bout of volatility, triggered by expectations of higher interest rates in the US, passed much of the sector by unnoticed: “There was some intra-day volatility in some of the more highly geared, specialist funds. Some of the trusts that had enjoyed strong demand from self-directed investors also proved volatile – Fidelity China, Scottish Mortgage and F&C Global Smaller Companies. However, those hoping to pick up cheap opportunities were disappointed.” There were a number of reasons why investment trusts didn’t exhibit panic selling. Notably, companies proved active in buying back shares. Scottish Mortgage, for example, bought back 3,000,000 ordinary shares at a price of 449.34p at the start of March. Walls added: “The boards are aware that discount volatility is not great for shareholders and did their best to manage discounts through this time.” However, while the rout itself did not throw up any conspicuous bargains, it did exaggerate some existing trends among some familiar investment trusts. The first is the weakness of the infrastructure trusts. There were seven infrastructure trusts among those trusts that saw the greatest discount widening over the period. In some cases, the moves were extreme - GCP Infrastructure saw a 9.4% move, while HICL saw an 8.0% move. 3i Infrastructure and John Laing Infrastructure moved from a long-standing premium to a small discount. Infrastructure trusts have long been seen as a ‘bond proxy’ investment and as such, might be expected to suffer on the prospect of rising rates. However, as Walls points out, there were also other factors at work. Concerns over the collapse of Carillion and an increasingly aggressive stance from the Labour Party on PFI have weighed heavily on investors. This has unquestionably led to better value, with discounts at multi-year highs. The question for investors is whether the rising interest rate environment is reflected in current prices, or whether any further inflation shocks could send prices lower still. Simon Moore, senior investment manager at Seven Investment Management (7IM) believes a more fertile ground may be the UK Equity income sector, where sentiment has been dented by Brexit concerns. He says: “There are three investment trusts which stick out where their price has fallen significantly over the last three months. All of these have Neil Woodford/ Mark Barnett connections (make of that what you will): Edinburgh Investment Trust, Perpetual Income & Growth and Woodford Patient Capital. “These have a few UK small caps that have been in trouble, arguably nothing to do with the market sell-off, but each manager have been vocal supporters of UK listed companies despite obvious global pessimism on UK equities post-Brexit referendum. If they are right - and their judgement calls have often been right in the past - then these funds could be rerated.” Moore points out that both managers have styles that will go in and out of favour. Certainly, all three trusts have moved down a long way. Patient Capital has seen its share price total return dip 10.7% and its discount widen 5.4%. Edinburgh Investment Trust hasn’t seen a significant change in its discount, which is hovering around 9%, but its shares are down 8.6%. It is a similar situation with Perpetual Income & Growth, where the shares are down 7.7%, but the discount remains at around 9.5%. Moore says: “It is worth remembering that Patient Capital is a very different fund to either Edinburgh Investment Trust or Perpetual Income and Growth and is not for the faint hearted. Given the nature of some of the companies it invests in, there may well be more ups and downs to come. But the clue is in the name - investors who can afford to be patient may well be rewarded over the long-term." Walls sounds a note of caution, saying that some of the classic equity income type stocks favoured by these two managers are still seeing a difficult time. Some of the outsourcing groups, for example, remain out of favour with investors. Much will depend on whether investors come to believe in the ‘value’ trade, where this type of stock will revert to more normal valuations. The other sector to see some change in ratings among the recent volatility has been the technology and media sector. Of course, this comes after a lengthy expansion in the technology sector, with companies such as Facebook, Amazon and Netflix leading markets higher for much of 2017. Walls says: “A couple of the technology trusts, such as Polar Technology Trust and the Allianz Technology Trust have moved to a small discount. I wouldn’t say they look like bargains.” Walls suggests that some sectors where there should have been bargains – such as UK smaller companies – have not seen any real movement in aggregate and are certainly ‘not exciting for value-minded investors’. That said, some are certainly cheaper than they were: Chelverton Growth trust has taken a hit, for example. The other weak trust has been the River & Mercantile UK Micro Cap, though this dropped following the departure of manager Philip Rodrigs over a ‘conduct issue’. Overall, most trusts have held up well since the start of the year. This reflects well on the sector, which appears to have grown better at managing market downturns. There are opportunities, but these have arisen from issues idiosyncratic to each sector rather than market volatility as a whole

More Content

More Content

Economic and Political Monthly Roundup January 2023

Companies: ADIG JFJ JII PCT HEFT ANII SDP SHRS MAVT TRY BEMO STS FCSS ABD EGL CSH GSF EBOX MLI SONG GCP

QuotedData Professional

Allianz Technology Investment Trust talk tech stocks

Companies: Attendo AB

Proactive

Economic and Political Monthly Roundup January 2023

Companies: ADIG JFJ JII PCT HEFT ANII SDP SHRS MAVT TRY BEMO STS FCSS ABD EGL CSH GSF EBOX MLI SONG GCP

QuotedData

Investment Funds - Buy the drop: Around the World with 20 Funds

Companies: JFJ IVI AJIT IAT MAJE THRG CTPE JEMA IGC FCSS JUSC ACIC ATT TPF WTR

Stockdale Securities

Global Macro Commentary & Investment Companies Roundup January 2023

Companies: ATT JII PCT MTE ANII SDV BGUK APEO API RICA ATST GCL FCSS PCFT ABD CIN EBOX WTAN SMT MTU BHMG CHRY VNH GIF CBA ATT

QuotedData

Useful Links

  • Features
  • Pricing
  • RNS/Newswires Feeds
  • Providers Hub
  • Company Hub

Account

  • Login
  • Free Trial - Join Now
  • Contact
Follow us on Linkedin Follow us on Twitter

Share:

Copyright © 2023 Research Tree | All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and Statement on Cookies

Research Tree will never share your details with third parties for marketing purposes. Research Tree distributes research documents that have been produced and approved by Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) Authorised & Regulated firms as well as relevant content from non-authorised sources, who are not regulated but the information is in the public domain. For the avoidance of doubt Research Tree is not giving advice, nor has Research Tree validated any of the information.

Research Tree is an Appointed Representative of Sturgeon Ventures which is Authorised and Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

Top
  • Home
  • Features
  • Pricing
  • Event Hub
  • Reg.News
  • Short Interest Tracker
  • Blogs
    • Academy
    • Insights
    • News
    • Research Tree
    • The Naked Fund Manager
  • Ideas & Picks
    • Ideas Hub
    • Stock Pick League
  • Explore Content
    • Regions
      • UK
      • Rest of EMEA
      • N America
      • APAC
      • LatAm
    • Exchanges
      • Aquis Apex
      • Australian Securities Exchange
      • Canadian Securities Exchange
      • Euronext Paris
      • London Stock Exchange (domestic)
      • SIX Swiss Exchange
    • Sectors
      • Automobile Industry
      • Banks
      • Building & Construction
      • Chemicals
      • Discretionary Personal Goods
      • Discretionary Retail
      • Energy
      • ETFs
      • Financial Services
      • Food & Drink
      • Food Production
      • Health
      • Household Goods & DIY
      • Industrial Equipment, Goods & Services
      • Insurance & Reinsurance
      • Investment Trusts
      • Leisure, Tourism & Travel
      • Media
      • Open-ended Funds
      • Other
      • Real Estate
      • Resources
      • Staple Retail
      • Technology
      • Telecoms
      • Utilities
    • AIC Sectors
      • Asia Pacific
      • Asia Pacific Equity Income
      • Asia Pacific Smaller Companies
      • Biotechnology & Healthcare
      • China / Greater China
      • Commodities & Natural Resources
      • Country Specialist
      • Debt - Direct Lending
      • Debt - Loans & Bonds
      • Debt - Structured Finance
      • Environmental
      • Europe
      • European Smaller Companies
      • Farmland & Forestry
      • Financials
      • Flexible Investment
      • Global
      • Global Emerging Markets
      • Global Equity Income
      • Global Smaller Companies
      • Growth Capital
      • Hedge Funds
      • India
      • Infrastructure
      • Infrastructure Securities
      • Insurance & Reinsurance Strategies
      • Japan
      • Japanese Smaller Companies
      • Latin America
      • Leasing
      • Liquidity Funds
      • North America
      • North American Smaller Companies
      • Private Equity
      • Property - Debt
      • Property - Europe
      • Property - Rest of World
      • Property - UK Commercial
      • Property - UK Logistics
      • Property - UK Residential
      • Property Securities
      • Renewable Energy Infrastructure
      • Technology & Media
      • UK All Companies
      • UK Equity & Bond Income
      • UK Equity Income
      • UK Smaller Companies
      • VCT AIM Quoted
      • VCT Generalist
      • VCT Generalist Pre Qualifying
      • VCT Specialist: Environmental
      • VCT Specialist: Environmental Pre Qualifying
      • VCT Specialist: Healthcare & Biotechnology
    • Trust Managers
      • 3i Group
      • 3i Investments
      • Aberforth Partners
      • abrdn
      • AEW UK Investment Management
      • Albion Capital
      • Allianz Global Investors
      • Alpha Real Capital
      • Amati Global Investors
      • Amedeo Air Four Plus
      • Apax Guernsey Managers
      • Aquila Capital Investment
      • Artemis Investment Management
      • Asset Value Investors
      • Athelney Trust
      • Atrato Partners Limited
      • Augmentum Capital
      • Axiom Alternative Investments
      • Baillie Gifford
      • Baker Steel Capital
      • Beringea
      • BlackRock Investment Management (UK)
      • Boussard & Gavaudan Asset Management
      • Brevan Howard Capital Management
      • Chelverton Asset Management
      • Columbia Threadneedle
      • CVC Credit Partners
      • Doric Partners
      • Ecofin
      • Fidelity
      • Foresight Group
      • Frostrow Capital
      • Fundsmith
      • Gravis Capital Management
      • Greencoat Capital
      • Gresham House
      • Hansa Capital Partners
      • Harwood Capital
      • ICM
      • InfraRed Capital Partners
      • Invesco Asset Management
      • J.P. Morgan Asset Management
      • Janus Henderson Investors
      • Jupiter Unit Trust Managers
      • KKV Investment Management
      • Liontrust Asset Management
      • Markel CATCo Investment Management
      • Maven Capital Partners
      • MD Barnard and Co
      • Mercia Asset Management
      • Montanaro Investment Managers
      • Neuberger Berman Europe
      • New City Investment Managers
      • Octopus Investments
      • Pantheon Ventures
      • Phoenix Asset Management
      • Polar Capital Holdings
      • Premier Miton
      • Puma Investments
      • Quaero Capital
      • Rampart Capital
      • Ravenscroft
      • Riverstone International
      • Schroder Investment Management
      • Schroder Real Estate Management
      • Seneca Investment Managers
      • Triple Point Investment Management
      • Tritax Management
      • Troy Asset Management
      • TwentyFour Asset Management
      • White Oak Capital Partners
      • Willis Towers Watson
      • YFM Private Equity
    • Small / Large Cap
      • UK100
      • UK250
      • UK Smallcap
      • UK Other Main Markets
      • Other
    • Private/EIS
      • EIS Single Company
      • EIS/SEIS Funds
      • IHT Products
      • SEIS Single Company
      • VCT Funds
  • Providers
    • Free/Commissioned
      • Align Research
      • BRR Media
      • Calvine Partners
      • Capital Access Group
      • Checkpoint Partners
      • Clear Capital Markets
      • Couloir Capital
      • Edison
      • Equity Development
      • eResearch
      • Fidante Partners
      • Five Minute Pitch TV
      • goetzpartners securities Limited
      • Hardman & Co
      • Inbound Capital
      • Independent Investment Research
      • InterAxS Global
      • Kepler | Trust Intelligence
      • London Stock Exchange
      • Magnitogorsk Iron and steel works
      • Mello Events
      • Mining Network
      • piworld.co.uk
      • Proactive
      • Progressive Equity Research
      • Quantum Research Group
      • QuotedData
      • RaaS - Research as a Service
      • Radnor Capital Partners
      • Research Tree
      • SEAL Advisors Ltd
      • ShareSoc
      • The AIC
      • Trinity Delta
      • UK Investor Group
      • Yellowstone Advisory
    • High Net Worth Offering
      • Fox-Davies Capital
      • Allenby Capital
      • AlphaValue
      • Alternative Resource Capital
      • Arctic Securities
      • Arden Partners
      • Auctus Advisors
      • Baptista Research
      • BNP Paribas Exane - Sponsored Research
      • Canaccord Genuity
      • Cenkos Securities
      • Couloir Capital
      • Dowgate Capital
      • finnCap
      • First Berlin
      • First Sentinel
      • Hannam & Partners
      • Hybridan
      • Kemeny Capital
      • Liberum
      • Longspur Research
      • Louis Capital
      • Magnitogorsk Iron and steel works
      • Medley Global Advisors
      • Northland Capital Partners
      • QuotedData Professional
      • Shard Capital
      • ShareSoc
      • Shore Capital
      • Singer Capital Markets
      • SP Angel
      • Stanford Capital Partners
      • Stifel FirstEnergy
      • Stockdale Securities
      • Tamesis Partners
      • The Life Sciences Division
      • VSA Capital
      • WHIreland
      • Whitman Howard
      • Yellowstone Advisory
      • Zeus Capital
    • Institutional Offering
      • Fox-Davies Capital
      • Align Research
      • Allenby Capital
      • AlphaValue
      • Alternative Resource Capital
      • Arctic Securities
      • Arden Partners
      • Atrium Research
      • Auctus Advisors
      • Baptista Research
      • BNP Paribas Exane
      • BNP Paribas Exane - Sponsored Research
      • BRR Media
      • Bryan, Garnier & Co
      • Calderwood Capital
      • Calvine Partners
      • Canaccord Genuity
      • Capital Access Group
      • Cenkos Securities
      • Checkpoint Partners
      • Clear Capital Markets
      • Couloir Capital
      • Dowgate Capital
      • Edison
      • Equity Development
      • eResearch
      • Fidante Partners
      • finnCap
      • First Berlin
      • First Sentinel
      • Five Minute Pitch TV
      • goetzpartners securities Limited
      • Hannam & Partners
      • Hardman & Co
      • Hybridan
      • Hypothesis Research
      • Inbound Capital
      • Independent Investment Research
      • InterAxS Global
      • Kemeny Capital
      • Kepler | Absolute Hedge
      • Kepler | Trust Intelligence
      • Liberum
      • London Stock Exchange
      • Longspur Research
      • Magnitogorsk Iron and steel works
      • Mello Events
      • Mining Network
      • Northland Capital Partners
      • Numis
      • Panmure Gordon
      • Peel Hunt
      • piworld.co.uk
      • Proactive
      • Progressive Equity Research
      • Quantum Research Group
      • QuotedData
      • RaaS - Research as a Service
      • Radnor Capital Partners
      • Research Tree
      • SEAL Advisors Ltd
      • Shard Capital
      • ShareSoc
      • Shore Capital
      • SI Capital
      • Singer Capital Markets
      • SP Angel
      • Stanford Capital Partners
      • Stifel
      • Stifel FirstEnergy
      • Stockdale Securities
      • Tamesis Partners
      • The AIC
      • The Life Sciences Division
      • Trinity Delta
      • UK Investor Group
      • Velocity Trade
      • VSA Capital
      • WHIreland
      • Whitman Howard
      • Winterflood Securities
      • Yellowstone Advisory
      • Zeus Capital
    • Video/Audio Interviews
      • BRR Media
      • Capital Access Group
      • Couloir Capital
      • Edison
      • Equity Development
      • Five Minute Pitch TV
      • Mining Network
      • piworld.co.uk
      • Proactive
      • QuotedData
      • RaaS - Research as a Service
      • Research Tree
      • UK Investor Group
      • Yellowstone Advisory
    • Event Providers
      • Capital Access Group
      • Cenkos Securities
      • Couloir Capital
      • Edison
      • Equity Development
      • Hardman & Co
      • InterAxS Global
      • Kepler | Trust Intelligence
      • London Stock Exchange
      • Mello Events
      • piworld.co.uk
      • Proactive
      • QuotedData
      • Research Tree
      • ShareSoc
      • Shore Capital
      • The AIC
      • UK Investor Group
      • VSA Capital
      • Yellowstone Advisory
  • Contact
  • Sign Up
  • Sign In