Research Tree Research Tree Logo

  • Try our Investor Tool
  • Login
  • Sign Up

Research Tree Logo

  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Features
  • Pricing
  • Reg.News
  • Contact
  • Try our Investor Tool
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Providers
  • Companies
⨯
LIVE

Event in Progress:

Join Here ×
  • Providers
  • Companies
⨯
  • Features
  • Pricing
  • Event Hub
  • Reg.News
  • Short Interest
  • Contact
Blogs >
The Naked Fund Manager >
Pension deficit dogs starting to look interesting
  • 05 Dec 16
title

Pension deficit dogs starting to look interesting

  • 2790 views
The Naked Fund Manager

UK-focused Small and Mid-cap fund manager.

 
Pension deficit sensitivity uk equities december 2016
Strap line

Pension deficits to start shrinking if discount rates mark-to-market

Companies: AGY, CHT, GNC, HRG, NXR, TUI


Body

 

Afternoon

 

Welcome to my weekly blog. I have a bit of a moan further down about the Constellation Healthcare deal, but before that, I mainly want to write about what you might call the "Pension Deficit Dogs" today. These are companies with large, poorly funded pension deficits that are particularly sensitive to the discount rates used to calculate future liabilities. I think they're starting to look interesting.

 

 

Identifying shares most sensitive to pension deficit change

The quick way I look at the landscape to get a snapshot of pension health for each UK listed company is to use a ranking system:

  • I take all UK-listed companies with pension obligations and rank them by how great the gross pension obligation is relative to market cap (1 for the best, and so on).

  • I then rank them by their pension funding ratio (i.e. Pension Assets/Liabilities) with the best funded getting a score of "1", second best a "2" etc.

  • By adding these ranks together and sorting the list from the largest number (i.e. worst) to the smallest you get a pretty clear idea of which companies are in a tricky spot.

The main chart above plots all relevant UK-listed companies, of which there is about 200, ordered by my "pension sensitivity" rank (stable/low rank on the left, highly sensitive/high rank on the right). I then plot the gross pension liability as a percentage of market cap on the y-axis.


The lowest ranked stock on this basis is Hogg Robinson, and I've highlighted a few others which also look particularly sensitive with respect to their large pension obligations. These include Clarke, Communisis, Coats, Renold, Norcros, Haynes Publishing Group, Heath & Sons, and Trinity Mirror.

 

 

So what? It's already baked into the price...

What's interesting is not that these companies have big pension obligations, that aren't well funded. This is already known and priced in. What is interesting, however, is how much these obligations could shrink next time the pension trustees mark their discount rates to the current yield curve.

 

Below is a scatter chart showing the discount rate used in each UK-listed companies' pension plan (sourced from Bloomberg).


pension plan discount rates across UK plc december 2016

 

The trend is blindingly obvious... most companies are using 3.5%-4% as a discount rate for their future expected pension cash outflows. However, there are some outliers on the downside like Norcros, Greencore, Allergy Therapeutics and Tui. Their pension plans are using 1.5%-2.3%.

 

In fact, Norcros only just cut its discount rate. It reported Interims to September last month (mid-November).  Management marked the discount rate to market with a big cut from 3.55% to 2.25% as UK yields had dropped materially post the EU referendum. The impact this had on its pension deficit was to nearly double it from £56m to £98m. The deficit has now grown from £22m in 2014, and £44m in 2015 when the last triennial valuation took place.

 

The yields had indeed bottomed out but have since rebounded as shown below and as I mentioned last week.

 

UK 10yr gilt

 

Will the next round of results see rising discount rates?

We may well see a series of discount rate increases if bond yields continue their march, and this could well be the case if President Trump continues to signal he will carry out his $1tn infrastructure plan.

 

Looking at these companies over the last year, they have all underperformed the FTSE 100 (orange line).

 

companies highly sensitive to pension discount rates

 

Clearly, there are other idiosyncratic factors at play but over the same period yields also consistently trended down to their trough in September.

 

 

Constellation bid leaving me bittersweet

Last week one of my big holdings Constellation (LON: CHT) was bid for by the CEO/founder Paul Parmar, backed by US private equity. CHT was a key, high-conviction holding for me.


Breaking down the bid, there was 235p in cash and 35p of a Promissory Note. We should ignore the cheeky "Promissory Note" which matures in 7 years, and hence the offer price is effectively 235p. Given this company is 100% US$ earnings, when you convert the offer back into $ it's a pretty small premium.


I'm unhappy with the bid, as I had high conviction the share was heading towards 300p. It had a decent pipeline of acquisitions and was now debt-free. On the flip side, I have made a decent return so I can't complain too much.


Mr. Parmar, the CEO, owned 52% already, so it looks like the deal will get done. Also, it is unlikely there will be another bidder. There is a big break fee in place to dissuade new entrants, and as I said, the CEO own 52%!


It's crucial for Management to have skin in the game, but this is an example where the rest of the shareholders are relatively powerless to do anything when the CEO has a majority, even if the price is too low.


Paul Parmar is not a popular individual, and if you read his blog you will understand why. In my opinion, some of the more colourful stories of his past led to UK fund managers never giving CHT the rating he wanted, to raise more equity for his acquisition strategy. So he's teamed up with US private equity to execute the same strategy away from public markets. I wouldn't be surprised if we see a NASDAQ IPO in a couple of years at a much higher multiple.

 

Promissory Note presents potential opportunity private investors

Many fund managers, including myself, will find it difficult to own the Promissory Note because many have restrictions that funds can only hold listed equity. This, in my view, is what's causing the big discount to the 270p total bid price. For private investors who might not mind holding a 5% coupon note, this creates an arbitrage opportunity whereby today shares can be bought for 213p that are ultimately worth 270p. As I say, it's not for me, but worth highlighting.


 

-----

 

To read a brief outline of how I think about stocks, and what I aim to achieve in this blog, please check out my first blog where I set out my stall.

 

Please Note: To be clear, I do not and will not ever give any advice. I will rarely mention individual stocks but when I do these will not be recommendations, instead just my thoughts at that point in time.

 


Body Two

Body Three

Body Four

Body Five

The information contained within this post is based on personal experience and opinion and should not be considered as a recommendation to trade nor financial advice.

More Content

More Content

SHORE CAPITAL - Greencore+ (GNC) House Stock, 76p

Companies: Greencore Group Plc (GNC:LON)Greencore Group Plc (GNCGF:OTC)

Shore Capital

Alergy Therapeutics: Trading Update July 2020

Companies: Allergy Therapeutics plc

Five Minute Pitch TV

Hybridan Small Cap Feast - 20 Jan 23

Companies: GHE AGY MIRI SLE DSW BIG

Hybridan

Allergy Therapeutics is 'firing on all cylinders' with strong cash position in full year results

Companies: Allergy Therapeutics plc

Proactive

Top Picks Playlist for 2023

Companies: GHHSCEBGOTPTZOOASTOINCHDWFEQLSNXR

Zeus Capital
next
 

Useful Links

  • Features
  • Pricing
  • RNS/Newswires Feeds
  • Providers Hub
  • Company Hub

Account

  • Login
  • Free Trial - Join Now
  • Contact
Follow us on Linkedin Follow us on Twitter

Share:

Copyright © 2023 Research Tree | All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Service and Privacy Policy and Statement on Cookies

Research Tree will never share your details with third parties for marketing purposes. Research Tree distributes research documents that have been produced and approved by Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) Authorised & Regulated firms as well as relevant content from non-authorised sources, who are not regulated but the information is in the public domain. For the avoidance of doubt Research Tree is not giving advice, nor has Research Tree validated any of the information.

Research Tree is an Appointed Representative of Sturgeon Ventures which is Authorised and Regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.

Top
  • Home
  • Features
  • Pricing
  • Event Hub
  • Reg.News
  • Short Interest Tracker
  • Blogs
    • Academy
    • Insights
    • News
    • Research Tree
    • The Naked Fund Manager
  • Ideas & Picks
    • Ideas Hub
    • Stock Pick League
  • Explore Content
    • Regions
      • UK
      • Rest of EMEA
      • N America
      • APAC
      • LatAm
    • Exchanges
      • Aquis Apex
      • Australian Securities Exchange
      • Canadian Securities Exchange
      • Euronext Paris
      • London Stock Exchange (domestic)
      • SIX Swiss Exchange
    • Sectors
      • Automobile Industry
      • Banks
      • Building & Construction
      • Chemicals
      • Discretionary Personal Goods
      • Discretionary Retail
      • Energy
      • ETFs
      • Financial Services
      • Food & Drink
      • Food Production
      • Health
      • Household Goods & DIY
      • Industrial Equipment, Goods & Services
      • Insurance & Reinsurance
      • Investment Trusts
      • Leisure, Tourism & Travel
      • Media
      • Open-ended Funds
      • Other
      • Real Estate
      • Resources
      • Staple Retail
      • Technology
      • Telecoms
      • Utilities
    • AIC Sectors
      • Asia Pacific
      • Asia Pacific Equity Income
      • Asia Pacific Smaller Companies
      • Biotechnology & Healthcare
      • China / Greater China
      • Commodities & Natural Resources
      • Country Specialist
      • Debt - Direct Lending
      • Debt - Loans & Bonds
      • Debt - Structured Finance
      • Environmental
      • Europe
      • European Smaller Companies
      • Farmland & Forestry
      • Financials
      • Flexible Investment
      • Global
      • Global Emerging Markets
      • Global Equity Income
      • Global Smaller Companies
      • Growth Capital
      • Hedge Funds
      • India
      • Infrastructure
      • Infrastructure Securities
      • Insurance & Reinsurance Strategies
      • Japan
      • Japanese Smaller Companies
      • Latin America
      • Leasing
      • Liquidity Funds
      • North America
      • North American Smaller Companies
      • Private Equity
      • Property - Debt
      • Property - Europe
      • Property - Rest of World
      • Property - UK Commercial
      • Property - UK Logistics
      • Property - UK Residential
      • Property Securities
      • Renewable Energy Infrastructure
      • Technology & Media
      • UK All Companies
      • UK Equity & Bond Income
      • UK Equity Income
      • UK Smaller Companies
      • VCT AIM Quoted
      • VCT Generalist
      • VCT Generalist Pre Qualifying
      • VCT Specialist: Environmental
      • VCT Specialist: Environmental Pre Qualifying
      • VCT Specialist: Healthcare & Biotechnology
    • Trust Managers
      • 3i Group
      • 3i Investments
      • Aberforth Partners
      • abrdn
      • AEW UK Investment Management
      • Albion Capital
      • Allianz Global Investors
      • Alpha Real Capital
      • Amati Global Investors
      • Amedeo Air Four Plus
      • Apax Guernsey Managers
      • Aquila Capital Investment
      • Artemis Investment Management
      • Asset Value Investors
      • Athelney Trust
      • Atrato Partners Limited
      • Augmentum Capital
      • Axiom Alternative Investments
      • Baillie Gifford
      • Baker Steel Capital
      • Beringea
      • BlackRock Investment Management (UK)
      • Boussard & Gavaudan Asset Management
      • Brevan Howard Capital Management
      • Chelverton Asset Management
      • Columbia Threadneedle
      • CVC Credit Partners
      • Doric Partners
      • Ecofin
      • Fidelity
      • Foresight Group
      • Frostrow Capital
      • Fundsmith
      • Gravis Capital Management
      • Greencoat Capital
      • Gresham House
      • Hansa Capital Partners
      • Harwood Capital
      • ICM
      • InfraRed Capital Partners
      • Invesco Asset Management
      • J.P. Morgan Asset Management
      • Janus Henderson Investors
      • Jupiter Unit Trust Managers
      • KKV Investment Management
      • Liontrust Asset Management
      • Markel CATCo Investment Management
      • Maven Capital Partners
      • MD Barnard and Co
      • Mercia Asset Management
      • Montanaro Investment Managers
      • Neuberger Berman Europe
      • New City Investment Managers
      • Octopus Investments
      • Pantheon Ventures
      • Phoenix Asset Management
      • Polar Capital Holdings
      • Premier Miton
      • Puma Investments
      • Quaero Capital
      • Rampart Capital
      • Ravenscroft
      • Riverstone International
      • Schroder Investment Management
      • Schroder Real Estate Management
      • Seneca Investment Managers
      • Triple Point Investment Management
      • Tritax Management
      • Troy Asset Management
      • TwentyFour Asset Management
      • White Oak Capital Partners
      • Willis Towers Watson
      • YFM Private Equity
    • Small / Large Cap
      • UK100
      • UK250
      • UK Smallcap
      • UK Other Main Markets
      • Other
    • Private/EIS
      • EIS Single Company
      • EIS/SEIS Funds
      • IHT Products
      • SEIS Single Company
      • VCT Funds
  • Providers
    • Free/Commissioned
      • Align Research
      • BRR Media
      • Calvine Partners
      • Capital Access Group
      • Checkpoint Partners
      • Clear Capital Markets
      • Couloir Capital
      • Doceo
      • Edison
      • Equity Development
      • eResearch
      • Fidante Partners
      • Five Minute Pitch TV
      • goetzpartners securities Limited
      • Hardman & Co
      • Inbound Capital
      • Independent Investment Research
      • InterAxS Global
      • Kepler | Trust Intelligence
      • London Stock Exchange
      • Magnitogorsk Iron and steel works
      • Mello Events
      • Mining Network
      • piworld.co.uk
      • Proactive
      • Progressive Equity Research
      • Quantum Research Group
      • QuotedData
      • RaaS - Research as a Service
      • Radnor Capital Partners
      • Research Tree
      • SEAL Advisors Ltd
      • ShareSoc
      • The AIC
      • Trinity Delta
      • UK Investor Group
      • Yellowstone Advisory
    • High Net Worth Offering
      • Fox-Davies Capital
      • Allenby Capital
      • AlphaValue
      • Alternative Resource Capital
      • Arctic Securities
      • Arden Partners
      • Auctus Advisors
      • Baptista Research
      • BNP Paribas Exane - Sponsored Research
      • Canaccord Genuity
      • Cenkos Securities
      • Couloir Capital
      • Dowgate Capital
      • finnCap
      • First Berlin
      • First Sentinel
      • Hannam & Partners
      • Hybridan
      • Kemeny Capital
      • Liberum
      • Longspur Research
      • Louis Capital
      • Magnitogorsk Iron and steel works
      • Medley Global Advisors
      • Northland Capital Partners
      • QuotedData Professional
      • Shard Capital
      • ShareSoc
      • Shore Capital
      • Singer Capital Markets
      • SP Angel
      • Stanford Capital Partners
      • Stifel FirstEnergy
      • Stockdale Securities
      • Tamesis Partners
      • The Life Sciences Division
      • VSA Capital
      • WHIreland
      • Whitman Howard
      • Yellowstone Advisory
      • Zeus Capital
    • Institutional Offering
      • Fox-Davies Capital
      • Align Research
      • Allenby Capital
      • AlphaValue
      • Alternative Resource Capital
      • Arctic Securities
      • Arden Partners
      • Atrium Research
      • Auctus Advisors
      • Baptista Research
      • BNP Paribas Exane
      • BNP Paribas Exane - Sponsored Research
      • BRR Media
      • Bryan, Garnier & Co
      • Calderwood Capital
      • Calvine Partners
      • Canaccord Genuity
      • Capital Access Group
      • Cenkos Securities
      • Checkpoint Partners
      • Clear Capital Markets
      • Couloir Capital
      • Doceo
      • Dowgate Capital
      • Edison
      • Equity Development
      • eResearch
      • Fidante Partners
      • finnCap
      • First Berlin
      • First Sentinel
      • Five Minute Pitch TV
      • goetzpartners securities Limited
      • Hannam & Partners
      • Hardman & Co
      • Hybridan
      • Hypothesis Research
      • Inbound Capital
      • Independent Investment Research
      • InterAxS Global
      • Kemeny Capital
      • Kepler | Absolute Hedge
      • Kepler | Trust Intelligence
      • Liberum
      • London Stock Exchange
      • Longspur Research
      • Magnitogorsk Iron and steel works
      • Mello Events
      • Mining Network
      • Northland Capital Partners
      • Numis
      • Panmure Gordon
      • Peel Hunt
      • piworld.co.uk
      • Proactive
      • Progressive Equity Research
      • Quantum Research Group
      • QuotedData
      • RaaS - Research as a Service
      • Radnor Capital Partners
      • Research Tree
      • SEAL Advisors Ltd
      • Shard Capital
      • ShareSoc
      • Shore Capital
      • SI Capital
      • Singer Capital Markets
      • SP Angel
      • Stanford Capital Partners
      • Stifel
      • Stifel FirstEnergy
      • Stockdale Securities
      • Tamesis Partners
      • The AIC
      • The Life Sciences Division
      • Trinity Delta
      • UK Investor Group
      • Velocity Trade
      • VSA Capital
      • WHIreland
      • Whitman Howard
      • Winterflood Securities
      • Yellowstone Advisory
      • Zeus Capital
    • Video/Audio Interviews
      • BRR Media
      • Capital Access Group
      • Couloir Capital
      • Doceo
      • Edison
      • Equity Development
      • Five Minute Pitch TV
      • Mining Network
      • piworld.co.uk
      • Proactive
      • QuotedData
      • RaaS - Research as a Service
      • Research Tree
      • UK Investor Group
      • Yellowstone Advisory
    • Event Providers
      • Capital Access Group
      • Cenkos Securities
      • Couloir Capital
      • Edison
      • Equity Development
      • Hardman & Co
      • InterAxS Global
      • Kepler | Trust Intelligence
      • London Stock Exchange
      • Mello Events
      • piworld.co.uk
      • Proactive
      • QuotedData
      • Research Tree
      • ShareSoc
      • The AIC
      • UK Investor Group
      • VSA Capital
      • Yellowstone Advisory
  • Contact
  • Sign Up
  • Sign In